EA Under Fire: Mythic R-99 Skin in Apex Legends Accused of Being Pay-to-Win

[COSMIN]

A new Mythic-tier skin for the R-99 SMG was released by Apex Legends developer Electronic Arts (EA) in a move that is stirring up the community. Many players are vocally denouncing this addition as “pay-to-win.” This launch sparks an uproar regarding cosmetic exclusivity and gameplay fairness in contemporary live-service shooters, since mythic skins are frequently expensive and obtained through exclusive means.

Why players are calling it “pay-to-win”

With Season 27, EA introduced a Mythic variant of the R-99 SMG, already known for its high fire-rate and minimal recoil when used properly. While the skin is primarily cosmetic, several players are arguing that this new exclusive skin gives the weapon a faster reload speed.

The new R99 skin seems to let you fire faster after a reload pic.twitter.com/ddswoN1EAY

— Skeptation (@Skeptation) November 7, 2025

Below are the main reasons fueling the backlash:

Although EA denies any change to stats, players believe the Mythic skin’s unique animations and visual feedback make target acquisition slightly easier. And the faster reload animation is causing havoc within the Apex Legends community.

Mythic skins are expensive in in-game currency or require luck via loot or packs, placing them out of reach for many free-to-play users. Some argue that even if mechanically identical, the psychological benefit of using a flashy “elite” skin can tilt player confidence or opponent perception.

EA’s stance & community response

EA has maintained that the Mythic R-99 skin does not provide any stat boosts, aiming to clarify that all weapons remain balanced regardless of skins. However, the company has yet to fully address the perception gap that many players feel.

In contrast, the community response has been vocal:

The R99 is pay-to-win

Influencers and YouTube clips labelled “P2W skin” have gained traction, indicating the controversy is impacting broader player sentiment.

The bottom line

Despite EA’s claim that the new Mythic R-99 skin is only cosmetic, the timing, visual effects, price, and community response indicate that many players do feel at a disadvantage if they choose not to use it. Depending on how EA handles pricing fairness, transparency, and possibly the future design of cosmetic tiers, the perception of “pay-to-win” might not go away any time soon.

For now, Apex Legends players and observers of the live-service shooter market should watch closely: this skin may be more than a simple aesthetic upgrade, and it might indicate a turning point in how cosmetics intersect with competitive perception.

The post EA Under Fire: Mythic R-99 Skin in Apex Legends Accused of Being Pay-to-Win appeared first on GameRiv.

View the full article